Agenda Item

6.1 9:02 A.M. - Public Input

   Oppose     Neutral     Support    
10000 of 10000 characters remaining
  • Default_avatar
    Margaux Kambara 30 days ago

    Dear Chair and Members of the Board,

    Attached for your review are:

    - An analysis of data-center restrictions adopted or being developed by California municipalities, including the apparent information threshold that prompted their response.

    - A relationship map supporting the synopsis prepared in response to the Board’s request for information about entities expressing interest in developing data centers in Lake County.

    - The synopsis submitted to the Board and others on October 6.

    - The presentation delivered at the Middletown Area Town Hall on October 8.

    I appreciate the work County staff and the Energy Policy Ad Hoc Committee have invested in this issue, but I disagree with their recommendation. My concern is with the recommended threshold for action. The Board asked the public to bring forward documented indications of interest. That information was provided in good faith, and the County’s recently published Fact Sheet acknowledges publicly stated development intent. Yet the committee continues to recommend waiting until an application is submitted before initiating a moratorium.

    That recommendation would place Lake County at the most reactive end of the response spectrum. Of the 37 jurisdictions classified in the attached comparison, 33 began responding at an information threshold below a submitted application. Their responses include directing policy work, preparing moratorium language, and adopting temporary or permanent restrictions. Although the circumstances differ, the comparison demonstrates that a submitted application has not been a necessary starting point for protective action elsewhere.

    I am also concerned that the Fact Sheet does not fully convey the documented activity associated with Red Hills Ranch Infrastructure and its affiliates. Publicly stated intent should be considered alongside steps toward that intent, including capital raising and XGS’s sustained engagement with the California Energy Commission on geothermal commercialization and the State’s Opt-In permitting pathway. By focusing on whether an application has been submitted through either the County or CEC pathway, the Fact Sheet reinforces waiting for that milestone while giving insufficient attention to documented actions advancing Red Hills and its affiliates’ publicly stated intent.

    I respectfully question whether the anticipated time needed to complete the County’s broader planning and environmental review justifies delaying interim protection. Other municipalities have proceeded with moratoriums while developing longer-term regulations. I respectfully request a detailed explanation of why Lake County cannot begin interim protections while other municipalities have done so: what specific obstacles prevent action now, what could be accomplished during a moratorium, and why those approaches would not work here.

    The Board should also evaluate a temporary moratorium while placing a permanent data-center prohibition before voters. A voter-approved prohibition could provide lasting protection beyond a temporary moratorium's duration.

    I am also concerned about the previous energy strategy presentation's proposal to recruit end users needing co-located baseload power. Data centers plainly fit that description.  The committee’s explanation that this language referred to an ammonia-based fertilizer plant is not supported by any documented local interest presented to the public for such a facility.

    In contrast, publicly stated intent to develop a data center has been documented and acknowledged by the County. Invoking a hypothetical fertilizer plant does not explain why the committee recommends recruiting users whose description directly fits the development already causing concern.

    The Board should take a clear position now. Recruiting end users needing co-located baseload power, without expressly excluding data centers, points toward encouraging the very development a moratorium would pause. The Board should resolve that contradiction by clarifying its recruitment policy and directing preparation of protective regulations.

    I ask the Board to direct preparation of a data-center moratorium for consideration, together with a work plan for longer-term protections, rather than make submission of an application the trigger for that work. Beginning preparation would allow the Board to evaluate concrete language, required findings, timing, and implementation options while it still has the opportunity to act proactively.

    Thank you for reviewing these materials and for your continued attention to protecting Lake County’s residents, resources, and future.

    Respectfully,
    Thomas Lajcik