Agenda Item

6a. 26-10209:05 A.M.- Public Hearing Consideration of proposed Major Use Permit, Kugelman Commercial Shop and Mitigated Negative Declaration (PL-25-271), for the approval of a 3,000-sf minor vehicle restoration and auto repair shop located at 15880 Kugelman Street, Lower Lake (APN 012-025-33).

   Oppose     Neutral     Support    
10000 of 10000 characters remaining
  • Default_avatar
    Donna Mackiewicz 29 days ago

    Subject: Public Comments – PL 25-271, 15880 Kugelman Street, Lower Lake – Biological Resources, Bird-Safe Building Design, and Tribal Cultural Resources
    Dear Planning Staff,
    Thank you for the opportunity to comment on Project PL 25-271, proposed at 15880 Kugelman Street in Lower Lake. I appreciate the County's efforts to review potential environmental impacts and incorporate recommendations from responsible agencies, including the California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW).
    After reviewing the available environmental comments and mitigation language, I respectfully request consideration of the following recommendations and clarifications before the County completes its environmental review.
    1. Support for CDFW Comment 2 – Bird Enhancement and Mortality Reduction
    I strongly support CDFW's Comment 2 recommending the incorporation of bird enhancement and mortality reduction strategies into the project's design and implementation.
    As CDFW notes, the proposed development will border existing open space that provides suitable habitat for nesting birds. Buildings adjacent to natural habitat can introduce new hazards, particularly collisions with transparent or reflective glass.
    These collisions are a significant source of preventable bird mortality. Birds may attempt to fly through transparent glass or toward vegetation and sky reflected in windows, resulting in injury or death.
    I respectfully recommend that the County incorporate CDFW's recommendations into the project's conditions of approval, including:
    • Bird-safe windows and glass: Require the use of bird-friendly glazing, such as fritted, acid-etched, frosted, ultraviolet-patterned, or other effective bird-visible glass treatments, particularly on windows facing open space and natural habitat.
    • Window screens and patterns: Incorporate exterior screens or appropriately spaced patterns that make glass visible to birds and reduce collisions.
    • Protection of nesting birds: Require a qualified biologist to conduct preconstruction nesting bird surveys when vegetation removal, grading, or construction activities are scheduled during the nesting season.
    • Active nest protection: Establish appropriate no-disturbance buffers around active nests, determined by a qualified biologist based on species, site conditions, and the nature of construction activities, until the young have fledged or the nests are no longer active.
    • Wildlife-friendly lighting: Minimize unnecessary nighttime lighting and use shielded, downward-directed fixtures to reduce disturbance to birds and other wildlife.
    • Native landscaping: Encourage locally appropriate native plants that support birds, pollinators, and other wildlife while minimizing the use of pesticides.
    I also encourage the County to consider established bird-friendly building design guidance from the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and other recognized conservation organizations.
    These measures are particularly important because bird collision hazards can persist throughout the operational life of a building. Incorporating bird-safe design during initial construction is generally more practical than retrofitting windows after bird mortality is documented.
    2. AB 52 Tribal Consultation – Middletown Rancheria
    Could I request clarification regarding the County's determination that the AB 52 tribal consultation process with Middletown Rancheria has been completed or closed.
    Please provide or identify the documentation supporting that determination, including:
    1. The date on which formal AB 52 consultation was initiated with Middletown Rancheria.
    2. Whether Middletown Rancheria provided written concurrence that consultation could be concluded, or whether the County relied upon another statutory basis for concluding consultation.
    3. Whether the Tribe identified any potential tribal cultural resources or requested additional investigation, consultation, or mitigation.
    4. The County's explanation of how the applicable requirements of Public Resources Code sections 21080.3.1, 21080.3.2, and 21082.3 were satisfied.
    Please clarify whether the County's decision to conclude AB 52 consultation was based on mutual agreement, a determination that no significant impact to a tribal cultural resource exists, or another legally supported basis.
    3. Clarification Requested – Mitigation Measure TCR-5
    In the first sentence of Mitigation Measure TCR-5, the timing requirement appears to need clarification.
    Is the intended requirement 45 days or 5 days prior to the specified activity? In the on-line material I was unclear but assume and hoped it is 45.
    Please review this language and correct it, if necessary, so that the required notification or consultation period is clear and enforceable.
    The timing is particularly important if the measure involves tribal notification, monitoring arrangements, or other actions that must occur before ground-disturbing activities begin.
    4. Incomplete Language – Mitigation Measure TCR-4(b)(iii) I also noticed that the language under TCR-4(b)(iii) appears to contain an incomplete sentence Please review this provision and provide the missing language so that the mitigation requirement is complete, understandable, and enforceable. It might just be an error.
    Thank you for your consideration and for the work involved in reviewing development proposals in Lake County.
    Respectfully,
    Donna Mackiewicz
    Lake County Resident